Imagine this: You and your best friend, Chris, go 50/50 on a duplex, never realizing how important a tool like Distribution in Kind could become when the partnership ends.
Suddenly, you’re at a crossroads, and the friendship feels strained. It seems your only two options are to sell this golden goose asset (and face a huge tax bill) or buy him out with cash you simply don’t have. You feel trapped.
But what if there was a third option? A way for Chris to get his share and for you to keep the property, all while kicking the tax can down the road? There is, but it’s a power you have to unlock before you ever buy the property with the right legal paperwork. It’s called a Distribution in Kind.
Table of Contents
What is Distribution in Kind?
A Distribution in Kind (DIK) is a formal way of saying that instead of selling an asset and distributing the cash, the business entity (like your LLC) distributes the asset itself to the owners.
To make it simple, think of your LLC as a special pizza oven you co-own with a friend, and the duplex is the pizza you’ve baked inside it.
- Selling: This is like selling the whole pizza to a stranger and splitting the cash.
- Distribution in Kind: This is like agreeing to dissolve the ‘pizza oven company.’ Your friend takes their half of the pizza, and you take yours. You both walk away with the actual asset, not the cash from its sale.
Why Not Just Sell? The Magic of Tax Deferral
When you sell an investment property, any profit is considered a ‘capital gain,’ and both you and your partners owe the IRS a chunk of that profit this year. A properly structured DIK, on the other hand, is a non-taxable event. You aren’t selling, you’re just changing the ownership from ‘the LLC’ to ‘you personally.’ The tax man doesn’t get involved yet because no sale has occurred.
Calculation Example:
Let’s say your duplex appreciated by $100,000. If you sell, you and Chris might each face a capital gains tax bill of $7,500 or more (depending on your tax bracket and other factors). With a DIK, that $7,500 stays in your pocket, continuing to work for you. You’ve deferred the tax on your own terms.
Crucially, this is tax deferral, not forgiveness. Your original cost basis (what you and your partners paid for the property, plus improvements) transfers to you personally. You’ll pay the taxes when you eventually sell, but you get to decide when that is.
| Feature | The Typical Path: Selling | The Savvy Path: Distribution in Kind |
| Immediate Outcome | You receive cash. | You receive direct ownership of the property. |
| Tax Implication | Capital gains tax is due now. | Capital gains tax is deferred to a future sale. |
| Control | You lose the asset. | You keep the performing asset. |
How Does This Actually Work?
While the specifics require professional guidance, the process generally follows these steps:
1. It All Starts with Your Operating Agreement
This option is only on the table if it’s explicitly allowed in your LLC’s Operating Agreement. Without it, you have no legal right to do this, and a forced sale may be your only option.
2. Agree on a Value
You and your partners must agree on the property’s current market value. This is typically determined by hiring a professional, third-party appraiser to ensure fairness.
3. Handle the Mortgage
The existing loan must be addressed. This often means the partner taking the property has to refinance it in their own name, paying off the old loan. Watch out for the due-on-sale clause (a mortgage term that requires the loan be paid in full upon any transfer of ownership).
4. The Legal Transfer
Attorneys and a title company will draft new deeds to transfer the property title from the LLC’s name into the individual owners’ names.
Sounds Too Good to Be True. What’s the Catch?
A DIK is a powerful tool, but it’s not a magic wand. Here are the common pitfalls.
- The Vague Agreement: A poorly written or non-existent operating agreement is the #1 deal killer. It leads to disputes and may force a sale you don’t want.
- Valuation Disputes: What if you can’t agree on a fair price? Your agreement needs a mechanism to resolve this (e.g., a pre-agreed appraisal process).
- Financing Hurdles: The partner keeping the property must be able to qualify for a new loan on their own. If they can’t, this option may not be viable.
- Professional Fees: This isn’t a DIY job. You’ll need an attorney and a CPA to execute the transaction correctly, so budget for their fees.
Your Action Plan: The Pre-Partnership Checklist
You might not need a Distribution in Kind for years, but the time to prepare is before you sign a single document. Treat this as a non-negotiable checklist for any partnership.
- Always Form a Legal Entity: Never buy property with a partner on a handshake. Form an LLC.
- Hire a Real Estate Attorney: Do not use a generic template from the internet. Pay a professional to draft your Operating Agreement tailored to your situation.
- Demand a Detailed “Exit Clause”: Ask your attorney to specifically outline what happens when one partner wants out, covering all scenarios (death, disability, disagreement, etc.).
- Insist on a DIK Clause: Ensure the right to a Distribution in Kind is explicitly written into your agreement as a potential exit path for the partners.
The Final Takeaway
Understanding concepts like Distribution in Kind is what separates amateur investors from strategic professionals. It’s about planning your exit before you even enter—and that’s how you build lasting wealth in real estate.
FAQs: Distribution in Kind
What does “in kind” mean in real estate?
In real estate, “in kind” means the asset itself is distributed rather than selling it for cash. A Distribution in Kind allows partners to divide property directly. This makes Distribution in Kind a unique tool compared to a traditional sale.
Is a Distribution in Kind always tax-free?
A Distribution in Kind is generally treated as a non-taxable event for federal income tax purposes. However, state rules may differ, so you should consult a CPA before relying on Distribution in Kind for tax planning.
Can a Distribution in Kind be used for assets other than real estate?
Yes, a Distribution in Kind can also apply to assets like stocks, equipment, or other holdings within a partnership. That said, the implications of a Distribution in Kind vary depending on the asset type and legal structure.
What if we can’t agree on the property’s value?
Disagreements can derail a Distribution in Kind, which is why a solid operating agreement is essential. Most agreements outline appraisal processes to resolve valuation disputes, ensuring the Distribution in Kind moves forward fairly.
Conclusion
Ending a real estate partnership doesn’t always have to mean selling a valuable property or taking a financial hit. With the right planning, Distribution in Kind offers a way to preserve your investment, defer taxes, and give each partner a fair outcome. The key is preparation—making sure your operating agreement has the right language before you ever buy a property together.
